New council housing approved on Brook Estate in Kidbrooke-Eltham

Proposals for 80 new council homes on the Brook Estate were last night approved by Greenwich Council’s Planning Board at the second time of asking.

The contentious plan covering an area at the edges of Eltham and Kidbrooke will see homes and a commercial unit built on green space within the estate, while other areas of greenery will see investment. The two hour long meeting – which can be viewed here – passed by six votes to one with a further three abstentions.

This green area is to be retained as others lost

A first meeting deferred a decision for a site visit, which was subsequently cancelled due to covid. In place a serious of images of the area shown on screen. A local campaign group named Save the Brooke complained that the council had not been accommodating to alternative proposals and engagement.

Development on green space

Kidbrooke and Hornfair Labour councillor David Stanley argued for fewer homes here and more at other sites, though there are a limited number of public sites – in part as Greenwich Council has previously sold off public land and buildings for short term gain. With the housing waiting list now up to nearly 20,000, households in emergency accommodation rising rapidly to 1,446 in late 2020 and housing budget overruns into the millions, there is an argument that all possible sites need utilising.

December 2020
Using sites suitably?

A severe level of need for secure housing makes proposals to build just 27 additional social homes at large-scale projects on public land – such as a new leisure centre and housing in central Woolwich containing up to 500 homes – so problematic. People will naturally wonder why their green space is taken when such minimal numbers are planned elsewhere, including other sites such as Plumstead where low density housing and extensive car parking was constructed last year in the midst of mid-density buildings near a station and bus routes.

Close up of low rise Plumstead housing beside taller buildings

It’s also understandable for people to be wary of areas only receiving investment in neglected estates when losing green space is on offer. This plot isn’t too far from the giant Kidbrooke Village estate and a major housing scheme from TfL yet next to no Section 106 or Community Infrastructure Levy income from those sites has improved the estate – an all too familiar story in Greenwich borough.

Just this month, Southwark Council once again show how Section 106 can improve communities as these plans were highlighted in a planning meeting:

Greenwich Council meetings never openly discuss Section 106 spending as a dedicated item on planning agendas.

Southwark spending

Perhaps if Greenwich did follow many other London authorities and invest in long-derived and neglected areas, they would face less opposition? To only offer something when taking something away is bound to cause irritation.

Public realm

There will be two zebra crossings as Greenwich claim TfL will object to pelican crossings. We’ve long heard this from Greenwich who like to blame TfL for many ills – despite Greenwich liking to insist on vastly outdated design with street work which often contravenes TfL’s own design guidance.

Perhaps TfL will object given current financial pressures though this is something Greenwich Council have stated for years which my experience in other authorities does not bear out – suggesting the issue is within Greenwich Council.

New homes will require regular parking enforcement – and Greenwich have a lamentable record here.

Design

ShedKM are behind designs which are similar in appearance to other sites across the borough. Many recent plans are ShedKM deisngs and recieved a luke-warm reception compared to Peter Barber’s previous design at various sites built in 2018-2019 including at nearby Jack’s Acre.

We again see attractive landscaping but the question is raised of who will maintain?

New homes

Building work on site should begin later this year and provide homes to 80 families. At current rates of growth in emergency need, that is about just 2-4 weeks of demand, which goes to highlight the severe issues and costs of the housing crises.

This website is a labour of love and almost entirely the work of one person. It takes much time and as a private renter, I'm not flush with money. Any help from readers is a massive help. You can make a one off payment or become a regular supporter through Paypal here

You can also contribute via my Patreon account by clicking here

John Smith

I've lived in south east London most of my life growing up in Greenwich borough and working in the area for many years. The site has contributors on occasion and we cover many different topics. Living and working in the area offers an insight into what is happening locally.

2 thoughts on “New council housing approved on Brook Estate in Kidbrooke-Eltham

  • January 20, 2021 at 3:42 pm
    Permalink

    The new council homes will be very much welcomed and provide much needed homes for people on the Boroughs housing waiting list.

    The commercial unit depending on size could be used for a supermarket for local residents or possibly a GP Surgery. As we do need more amenities across the borough.

    Reply
  • January 25, 2021 at 8:53 am
    Permalink

    Good to see new council homes being planned for sites around the Borough. I hope more sites for further council homes to be built will be identified soon.

    I also agree that we do need a lot more amenities around the Borough as more and more new homes are built across the Borough and the local population grows.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.